Ladies, nice guy needs your advice!?

Ok, so... All my co-workers and friends say that I'm really cute or good looking and are totally surprised that I don't have a gf. They also say that I'm a really nice, hard to find kind of guy, but not a push over. Apparently opening doors for a girl is unusual now a days? I just grew up that way. It's kinda starting to bug me that I don't have a gf. I happen to live in one of those towns where most people gets married right out of high school and I've been out of the dating game for a year, just kinda gave up. Ya I've been to the clubs and bars. Not really for me. (its fun to cut loose even though I look like a dying baby seal on the dance floor, lol) I'm not that fat. About me: I go to Cross fit 4-5x a week, dirt bike, hike, snowboard, own a house, juggle college with work. I'm 24, 6'3" 205lbs. Have plenty of friends that are girls but not a girl friend, and no I'm not gay. Just want a girl whose semi active, has some christian morals, and is down to earth. Not really into the one night stand or spring break fling stuff. In high school I had no problem with girls, and so I'm not a 40 yr old virgin or anything but i did grow up, just somehow lost my swag. Where would I find a girl like this? Tips on getting my game up to par? Any ideas?